I'm really hoping nobody asks me if I'm going to watch the Barbie movie because then I have to explain I don't like Greta Gerwig as a screenwriter. I don't think she writes bad movies, she co-wrote Barbie with her husband, he wrote Marriage Story (I thought they co-wrote it) and she wrote Lady-Bird. She is a good director, she's done a bunch of great stuff. I only disliked the monologue in Marriage Story from Laura Dern, but now I realise that was unfair because that was her husband Noah Baumbach. It seems like they've both made some kind of long needed cohesion in the gender war whereby they've subversively shown everyone both sides are wrong and need to work together.
Throw everything I was about to say in the fucking bin, I like them. It was more my bitterness towards Marriage Story's plot and characterisation, and that I didn't like Lady Bird because I didn't like the main character and her strained relationship with her mother. Which was what made me uncomfortable.
Trouble is, I saw the speech from Barbie, and the way it's even framed is like, Barbie's Scarlet Johansson sitting looking up at the domineering Laura Dern, this time played by America Ferrera, as her character rants about how hard it is to be a woman. I know people like to hear it, but it's been said. It was a lot of regurgitated talking points from before Hillary didn't get elected. I was ranting at being called brainwashed for supporting Bernie and asking women, okay do you want a woman in charge or the right woman? Because just wanting a woman in charge isn't enough for me. I want Bernie because he's right for the job, if AOC were running I'd be rooting for her, not Hillary. But the clip is out of context to the film itself, which may be suggesting this isn't right either. This is why I chose humanism instead of feminism. I've been sick of this war between the sexes which just got repackaged as the wage gap. I'm sick of seeing women telling men they need to get a vasectomy without general anesthetic because they suffered through a birth. You're both wrong and right. Men need to speak up when women are in pain and being ignored, women need to remember men still suffer pain. You're never looking for equal ground, you're always kicking men and not the patriarchy, who's fucking both of us. Attack Jordan Peterson and Ben Shapiro, don't attack men in general. Attack the ideas not the people. Men need to do better, we all need to fucking do better.
Sorry, Greta, I take it back I do like you just your movies aren't for me. If you influenced Noah's speech written for Laura, that's great, it's just I don't need a lesson on the Madonna/Whore complex. If he's conversely influenced you to be so subversive you might have broken people's fucking brains with a Barbie movie (I hope so), that's a good thing. People allegedly don't know what to do or how to react to the Barbie Movie and it's a good thing. It might've brought this culture war to a head. Guys are leaving their girlfriends over it due to not coping with sexism as a concept, little girls are asking "what's a patriarchy?". Maybe we need this. It's drawn attention away from Oppenheimer's rhetoric. If you don't know how to respond to Barbie, that's okay. It's just, I don't need what it's selling, I was tuned in before. Nobody's right. We need to start over.
Everything I suspected from what I heard was confirmed, I read Gerwig's entire approach to this and she specifically stated she wanted to make a humanist narrative. I'm sorry. She is a genius. She did do something subversive and new and different and she broke people's brains as a result. I feel like this movie can only make sense to humanists. It can only exist in the context of actual humanism. She borrowed from so many texts and concepts, there's a huge amount of intellectualism involved while still being in the realm of bubblegum comedies like Legally Blonde, which is also an inadvertent masterpiece. She's finally done what nobody has done to this degree. Please let this movie make a billion dollars. Please let this be an actual turning point in our basic bitch mentality around who's the better sex and admit everyone has a place and a reason and a purpose, and between us we can fucking figure it out. Let this be the thing that finally makes right wing idiots afraid of wokeness look absolutely stupid to everyone else. Let this be the reason we don't bring gender into politics anymore. Fuck. Barbenheimer has its on Wikipedia entry. This is important. I'll watch the movie eventually I've gotten enough from the plot synopsis and Gerwig's approach. Thank fuck this fell out of Amy Schumer's hands, sincerely I'm so glad she left the whole thing her brand of feminism is dumb and toxic. This movie didn't actually need feminism to exist. It needed a married couple who understood humanism on a base level and could finally package it as something wholly benign and sensible. That you can have your feminism and eat it too, ladies. Come hang with the humanists. We can get this shit done. You'll see. I see now why Ken took such a central part in the marketing. Of course this is weird to people who put up with gender norms without realising gender is becoming redundant on many levels. The Barbies don't defeat the Kens, the Kens don't enslave the Barbies. They deconstruct the utopia Barbie exists in. Gerwig's a genius. Give this woman more money and awards and let her make these movies. Fuck everything I said, don't listen to me. I don't know shit. She's amazing.
Now there's a weird phenomenon where darling movies getting Oscar noms are now being torn down as "not as good as people said it was", Everything, Everywhere being one example. Barbie's now back in the spotlight because of its lack of accolades and Robbie being snubbed while Gosling wasn't. It managed to get a Golden Globe for making a shitload of money. And yeah, maybe that's all it really did. Gerwig isn't up for Best Director, she's got to share Best Adapted Screenplay with husband ("adapted" because it's about an existing product, not original for being an original story, even though Critics' Choice recognises it as Original). Meanwhile, it's still up for Best Picture, Best Supporting Actor and Actress, it has two fucking Best Original Songs, Best Production and Best Costume. All of which I can accept based on what I know. Soon as people were shitty about Oppenheimer getting Best Hair and Make Up while Barbie, it only made no sense to me for a second. Oppenheimer has to transform actors into historical figures, and it's a period piece. You can't just make a bunch of women look pretty with nice hair and make up despite that being a facet of Barbie as a doll. Sorry, again, it appears this is where the film is actually lacking. The costumes and production design do look deserving of acknowledgement, from what I saw, an immense amount of effort went into those aspects. I thought all the others made sense, but yeah, someone's pointed out how contradictory the screenplay is, and Gerwig failed to get her point across as a director, so I don't think these are bad decisions. I'm not sure about Best Supporting Actress for America Ferrera, from what I saw, she was just reading out Twitter rants in her speeches. I should watch the movie but the same time I can see myself just cringing at so many points I'm supposed to be uplifted by... kinda like when I watched fuckin' Wonder Woman. They probably are going to age poorly for all the hype they had about being feminist/female-centric productions. I don't think the Oscars have fucked up on this one. I don't think Billie Eilish needs another Oscar, so it will be funny if the Ken song wins, as it's also doing better awards-wise. Insanely, it's smacked the Grammys in the face with so many options it's kinda scary. It's doing well at feminist based awards ceremonies, it'd be kinda weird if it didn't. But this is where I rip my hair out over "feminist" movies doing "well", they just don't get picked apart the way they should be.
Having said this, the backlash is now apparent and I'm halfway through a video justifying why Barbie might actually be a mediocre movie. The person's made good points (I'm ignoring their pronunciation of a lot of words, people really are in their saying words how they sound era) and they've compared America Ferrera's monologue to other movies, I wish they'd also included Marriage Story as it proves they're into writing "mouthpiece" characters who are quite rounded and relatable but are still standing up making a huge, impassioned speech about how hard it is to be a woman. (I persistently forger Noah wrote and directed Marriage Story, reason being is that part feels like a Greta moment). The movie revolves around political talking points, there were other ways this movie could've been presented with more interesting ideas but I think if Greta had been too nuanced it wouldn't have been received that well. It was already contentious as to how good it was, people were lukewarm. So now I know I'd be going into a very predictable movie with a lot of talking points, I'm less inclined to see it now. I think I'd cringe because you're not selling me anything new, it was only new to women under 20. So I don't think she's this amazing writer that should get more awards. I think the awards shows are basing their decision on this not being a standout movie or script. It's a shame. I think having other people come out and argue it was snubbed for awards is also incredibly misguided when the only thing it has to boast about is box-office sales. And they made an award just to reward it for that so people wouldn't get mad. I can't see Gerwig and Baumbach becoming a powerhouse couple who can be relied upon to keep writing successes. It appears Greta can't world build because she's never had to create a new environment. That's not her fault it's not up to writers to write new worlds, but she's never worked in a new world so it seems like she could only base Barbie within a framework of reality alone. So they had to pull the "don't think about it too much" card once the world dynamics are brought into question. It's an existential movie that doesn't want the audience to "think too hard". That's so stupid. Especially when the writers admitted themselves said, there's no story here, there's no character. It's why it's been so difficult to get it off the ground. But there were stories to draw on, and it wasn't given to the right people, so Amy Schummer was probably just as bad but maybe she had a story. Gerwig and Baumbach are very specific directors and writers who write intimate movies and they foolishly used this as a vehicle for a message they've already explored mulitple times in other films.
And it appears Gerwig signed her husband on for the whole thing, didn't tell him, left him to find it out from the press, then he couldn't fucking escape. Is it possible they could've been close to divorce over this? That's icky. That's such an icky concept roping your unwilling partner into a project without asking, or if they did ask and the partner said no and they still did it anyway, and clearly didn't ask because they were sure the answer would be no... you know, how MEN ROPE WOMEN INTO SHIT WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT BECAUSE MARRIAGE. WHAT THE FLYING FUCK? I really want to raise the role-reversal theory on that, like if James Cameron roped Katherine Bigalow into a whole ass, major production against her will and she'd tried to get out of it and couldn't, people would be fucking outraged. But when Greta does it, it's somehow cute and hilarious. Honestly, I know this sounds mean and I think they have a reasonably solid relationship, but I would still find it hilarious if that destroyed their marriage. They have a very obvious communication issue that was explored in Marriage Story, so was this a cry for help the way Angelina and Brad did a movie about a disintegrating relationship right before theirs disintegrated? It seems kind of subliminal that they can't communicate unless it's via creating a project and exploring the issues in a fictional arrangement. Now I'm just fascinated by them as a couple.
Nothing about this is actually humanistic. Not if the very concept and development of it wasn't even founded on a fair arrangement between a man and a woman who wanted to genuinely work on it. You had to drag a man kicking and screaming into its development, and then the only man who carried in terms of acting is the one getting rewarded directly. Congrats ladies, y'all done played yourselves again. (I know America Farrera has been nominated for supporting, and supporting categories are valid but it's not fair for Margot, according to everyone else. I'm more inclined to disagree than before. I don't think she deserves a nomination, and I don't think Gerwig should be given any best director nominations. Unless the competition was that much weaker, then it wouldn't have been earned). Anyway, I have flipflopped on my approval of Greta so hard during this whole thing and now I've gone back to not liking her. I don't think she's a genius for making a humanist movie because I don't think she's succeeded in bridging the ridiculous divide between the genders at all. It hasn't solved the wage gap, and I don't think she particularly cares if abortion rights exist or not. Best you could do was say women deserve better. Wow, big statement. Much progress.