I just had a major revelation about Heathers and the three girls in particular that I have to flesh out. There's a subtle moment in the film where we see how devious Heather Duke can actually be when you give her incentive, how clever she is compared to Heather Chandler, the self-appointed leader. Also, the three Heathers actually represent three separate social classes in the school. Heather C is the obvious prep, but cheerleader Heather McNamara is technically a sporto. Meanwhile, Heather D is a geek. Without Veronica, the three Heathers have far less in common. Their unification is their name, and their economic status. But that's about it. How did they become the most powerful clique in school? We don't know, but somehow they did, and by rights you feel like none of them should be friends in reality. All they can do is get together and make everyone else feel awful to make themselves feel good. We get a vague idea of the dynamics of the group in the opening montage, but we don't get a sense of who's who in depth until the cafeteria scene. We establish the technical minions first, Heather M and D. Heather M exerts her power over Veronica with physical force, Heather D spinelessly reiterates the demand from the top, and Veronica surrenders with reluctance. Then we're introduced to Heather Chandler with more grandiosity. She turns like a classic movie villain to address Veronica and the audience. Her dominance and importance is properly established here. As far as openings go, we get a lot from the croquet scene without getting too much. When Veronica says, "Heather told me she teaches people real life," we know it has to be the Heather that hit her with the red ball previously. But how evil is this Heather, really? We don't know until the cafeteria scene.
Heather Chandler may hold all the power but she's not smart or even clever. She only knows how to play the game. She's risen to power, we don't even know how the hell she got there other than she was ruthless and willing to do what it takes. Really, that's included sleeping with certain guys and getting in with college boys, all while making all the girls around her feel small and inferior. Did she take down another girl in the position? She's only a junior and she's got everyone eating out of her hand, they all want her as a friend or a fuck, even if Veronica knows they think she's a piranha. She's grown up rich, she can have anything, she sets herself apart from everyone, even her own clique, and she is genuinely depressed. If we pay more attention to the frat party montage, we see how disgusted she is in having to blow guys to keep her power. She's trying to make sure she's not a nobody when she graduates and goes to college, but she's still going to hate herself anyway. (There's a missing scene in the script where we discover Heather D has gotten together with Heather C's college boyfriend David, and she's blowing him offscreen, so he's clearly unaffected by Heather C's death and Heather D is determined to replace her in every sense). The suicide note is a true reflection of Heather C, she was misunderstood, she had feelings that went unacknowledged and she was used by people despite her power at school. Veronica only sees the bitchiness, she has the slightest moment of regret going through Heather C's locker and seeing the evidence they used to be good friends. But we don't have the full reason Veronica wanted in, she just wanted in. I could reference the musical fleshing this out in one of the opening numbers, but I refuse to apply it here, I'm only talking about what we see in the movie. There's enough evidence Heather genuinely wanted to kill herself, even JD sees it looking over the magazines in her room after she's splashed through the coffee table. In that one shot, he's got Heather down in a way Veronica could never see her. It's not even a moment of sympathy, in his eyes it's a stroke of genius and it pays off so well Veronica feels like this is all too natural to him.
Heather D, on the other hand, is genuinely intelligent, but she's also very much a geek. She's more classically beautiful, and Heather C has figured out how to make her feel disgusting and small, and as empty-headed as a pillowcase. I'd hazard a guess Heather C knows damn well Heather D could be more and do more and has to keep her down so she can't usurp power. Heather M might not get shit from Heather C, she gets to play along dog-piling on Heather D and Veronica, the two of them really are on the bottom rungs of the hierarchy, but Heather M will never make a play for the crown. As long as she's basically second in command, she's safe. She's allowed to keep cheer leading and she's supposed to have a jocky as fuck boyfriend in Ram, the himbo. She's the sporto representation, and she's also rich and profiting off her parents' wealth and status. She has it all figured out, or so she thinks. Once Heather C and Ram are dead, Heather M's world is upside down. Her boyfriend turned out to be gay (so she thinks, she doesn't even question Veronica and JD's manipulation of Ram's sexual preference) and she's affected by the fact he killed himself after sleeping with her, not even that he might've been sleeping with his best buddy. Everything feels wrong, and she's in no place to take over as the head student of the social network at Westerburg. Heather D knows this, soon as Heather M outs herself on the radio, Heather D is ready to strike even though Heather M isn't even a threat to her rising popularity. Heather D has enough call for revenge, Heather M never really protected her from Heather C, but Heather M turns out to be the nicest one. Veronica comes to her rescue for more than just preventing a real suicide. She cares enough about her friend to stop her. Heather D would've reveled in being the only Heather left, she wanted Heather C out of the picture no matter what and if Heather M has to go, so be it. She gets the crown, and she stands alone. Heather M might really be the most naive and foolish one of them, but she is not the worst Heather.
Heather D's rise to power is masterful compared to Heather C's. The one moment we see she's genuinely a better manipulator is when she's getting everyone to sign JD's "petition". Rather than moan and groan about having to speak to the "scum of the school" like Heather C, Heather D assumes the guise of whichever group she approaches. Every cut in the montage, she's dressed more like the kids she's trying to win over, and she lies to every person about the reason for the petition. She doesn't just use whatever cache she has being a Heather, she may be "red" now, but she'll stoop in ways Heather C never would to get her way, and she takes absolute pride in it. The shot of her basking in her glory is one of my favourite shots from a movie ever. I use it when I'm feeling victorious. The lengths she'll go to just to do JD's bidding, win total domination and smash everyone including Veronica, she was always the most ruthless, the most manipulative and the most diabolical. All she needed was Heather C to get out of the way, she straight up prayed for Heather C's death. She can ditch her eating disorder and do Chinese at the food fair with her new friends. And she can wear Heather C's entire wardrobe, as she admits in the TV interview she does after Heather C's death. It's a subtle hint early on she might use that to her advantage. She's an immediate attention seeker suddenly on all the news channels falsely lamenting the death of her arch rival and best friend, (same difference, remember?).
Heather D is the Queen Bee from the beginning. It looks like her taking over is more sudden than it is, JD knows he can cash in on her bad side with the right leverage by threatening to out her as the school punching bag Martha Dunstock's childhood friend. He inspires her to manifest her existing lust for power, it's not like she had no intention until he showed up. We even see a subtle difference in her outfits before she turns red, everything's a little grey and pink and a lot less green the more confident she gets. The iconic red scrunchy simply seals the deal. JD's got the Heathers figured out from the very start, and Veronica just fills in the blanks for him. He wants to tear them down for Veronica, but once Veronica's gone, he still needs to finish what they started, she's inspired him to exact his own revenge that he may or may not have followed through on without her. He pulls the gun on Kurt and Ram, we can guess he's done similar things at the six other schools he went to. The only thing Heather D is genuinely dumb about is him and his true intentions. She revels in knowing JD's attention gets under Veronica's skin, but JD adores Veronica in his own fucked up way, and he does want Heather D to die, Veronica playing with the idea is perfect for him but Veronica's over it, and over him. The dream sequence is probably one of the best scenes in terms of playing with the idea of the futility of offing Heather D. Veronica finally has a moment where she sees herself possibly becoming the enemy, and how replaceable she is.
Ultimately, we know Veronica will win, she's the new sheriff and Heather D will go the way of Heather C, fading into insignificance as she moves on to college. Heather D won't have a friend like Veronica, who was looking out for her all along, she'll have Swatch dogs and Diet Cokeheads for friends the rest of her life, she'll date guys like David who'll use her until the next hot piece of ass comes along. Veronica's way is the way, not JD's, or Heather's, or Miss Phlegm's
Veronica's going to be best friends with Betty Finn, Heather M and Martha Dunstock. Maybe things will get better and her high school will be the nice place she wants to be. It doesn't make Heather D any less of a tyrant. You get sucked into her meekness, she is an ingenue who's waiting for her moment, and having a chance to be Heather C's clone is the only way she can do this. You can see how uncomfortable Heather M is by this time, you know she's getting shit from Heather D, Veronica's either with JD all the time dealing with his bullshit or avoiding him and everyone. Heather M's got no real friends left, not even the other girls on the squad like her, they don't let her be captain of the team, her parents are "divorced and stuff". She's the most hard done by of the group, who is she without the clique? Who is she without status? Just another lonely rich kid. We're led to believe Heather M might be in charge the way she manipulates Veronica into going on a double date with Kurt and Ram, she doesn't exactly come in and refute Kurt's claim that he and Ram got with Veronica later that night, she doesn't even challenge that with Ram. She's nowhere around, she's off on the sidelines with a yet transformed Heather Duke, laughing at Veronica and JD fighting in the car. She doesn't see Heather D's lust for power until it's too late, she just notices Heather D's not cowering and simpering anymore. She doesn't even care that much Heather C is dead (she’s not in a state over it, she didn’t value Heather C, like everyone else’s prayer, hers is shallow and self-centred, and maybe she didn’t get along that well with Heather C) or put it together why Heather D no longer has the urge to purge. She really has to fall from grace to appreciate Veronica's loyalty. How they end up is perfect, but that one scene in the bathroom is all we get, Heather M's fate's up in the air as to whether she'll keep being a cheerleader or drop out, or where she was even going to college, if she'll graduate at all since she's failing math. Everything we know about her life doesn't become obvious until after Ram dies and she's out in the cold. Again, is she a Heather because she's named Heather, or because she's rich and a cheerleader that the principal would be willing to take half a day off in mourning her? She's got the right attitude to fuck with the eagles, she's got the right looks. But we don't see her and Heather C becoming friends over mutual interests, anymore than we see Heather D divorcing Martha Dunstock for the privilege of being socially powerful.
We don't need to see how the Heathers came to be to accept they just are, but I found it more interesting how there's little to bind them to each other outside of the names. Heather C would never be friends with a member of the geek squad, but she can obviously exploit Heather D and Veronica's desperation to be popular by throwing them a bone. Long as they both do as they’re told. Heather M's a sporto, she's already got social cache by dating someone on a team and being in a squad that would only employ preppy, pretty girls who'd look hot in a uniform, so Betty Finn and Martha are out. But you take all that away from Heather M and she essentially has nothing. I like that we're tricked into thinking she's about to take the helm and that Heather D would absolutely never. It makes Heather D's behavior more fun to watch. Shannon Doherty really did peak with this role, she's the best at doing meek and mild as well as mega bitch. My brother couldn't convince me to watch Heathers because he told me it's a movie where Brenda Walsh gets it in the neck. I saw it by the end of primary school, I don't even remember the first time I did see it, but it infected my brain on a level Breakfast Club hasn't managed to achieve. I watch it way more often than any of my favourite John Hughes movies, even at 12 I had this distinct impression people would never be fair and nice so why would I ever be? I did see it before I saw the Breakfast Club, with my mind, it makes way more sense for me to adore Heathers over the Breakfast Club.
I
had to explain to someone on Twitter how Heathers is the ultimate
anti-John Hughes movie. It paints a more realistic picture of social
circumstances in high school compared to the Breakfast Club. I don't
even believe we can get along in heaven, but really the sentiment JD's
getting at is, we'll be equal when we're dead and buried. The one thing I
could never buy was him killing everyone because he's so fundamentally
unloved. He blows himself up realising Veronica's got the balls to
really fix shit when he doesn't. There's a weird scene in one of the
drafts of the script where everyone's at a heavenly prom, the punch bowl
is full of liquid drainer, and all the students are dancing together
and getting along, as per JD's dream. I like this isn't in the film, to
be honest. I like the way it actually ends. It's more satisfying we never get to go to prom. We see kids pulling down Miss Phlegm's stupid banners while they run outside to see what happened. Comically, nobody cares about Veronica's state besides Heather D, who's naive to the truth Veronica really is about to knock her off her perch. She gets to make amends with Martha without consequence and ride off into the sunset. (I even realised Veronica can't call in a bomb threat to the cops without implicating herself in the murders. She has to play it the way she does to keep off the hook, and the truth dies with JD.)
Anyway, I had to get all that out there.
I want to add an addendum dedicated to Peter and how he's actually the worst character in the movie. I was thinking about the note scene with Miss Phlegm and how he realises Heather was dissatisfied with her life and he wasn't boring. Veronica obviously laughs since she knows the truth, but it only occurred to me he's happier believing he wasn't the problem, Heather being dead isn't an issue for him, plus he gets clout for having dated her, and winning her a rhino at the 4H club (I think this implied they were dating in junior high or much earlier in high school). We know everyone's relating to how her death affects them, there's no real sympathy for Heather, her death makes everyone seem more sympathetic. This movie doesn't get enough credit for the issues it did explore around suicide and everyone acting like they loved the deceased and were closer to them than they were, and how it makes them sad when they probably didn't care or genuinely wanted the person dead. But Peter probably spends the most time worrying about his own ass. He runs the food drive for cred in the year book, and hates Heather's death gets the front page while he's crammed in by the Taco Bell coupon. He's only worried about his college applications and getting Ivy League acceptance, he needs a VHS copy of the "love-in" on the TV for his Princeton application. He prays to God to never befall the same fate as Heather. Everything he does is in service to him and his application, or if he did win a million dollars, he can only think of it in terms how much he'd get after taxes, there's no mention of him doing anything wild or pointlessly noble with it. He's about as bad as Miss Phlegm, his agenda's awful. We see him hanging with another girl at the end, the pep rally has everyone "getting along" right before they're about to die. I just had a look at the Wiki entry on him and apparently he "cares" about Veronica getting double-teamed by Kurt and Ramm. He actually gives Veronica a lot of fake sympathy and he still finds the rumor amusing despite Veronica's disgust. Sadly, the actor later committed suicide so it's sad to think he probably identified with the subject matter without any meaningful acknowledgement.
I could write hit pieces of sorts on most of the characters. I mean, Betty Finn and Martha Dunstock are the good guys. I like Veronica's stuck between those worlds and we don't know why she sacrificed one for the other, just that she regrets it completely. If it was ever a lesson in choosing the right friends and how easy it is to be influenced by assholes, you'd think more teenagers now would watch it. I don't know if the musical got them into the movie, the musical seems to be too invested in solving a problem of glorifying suicide by mistake, like Christian Slater's entirely to blame for the incel community existing. You weren't supposed to agree with him, once again you missed the point. (He didn't do the same thing in Pump up the Volume either but somehow Christian Slater's duffle jacket, proto-emo, sad boy 90s routine was misread by everyone). Weirdly, the Mean Girls musical movie (that nobody asked for) came out to a tepid response and of course people compared it to the Heathers musical and said the musical version was "better". I found someone's "oh dear" response and added I was annoyed the musical was trying to fix the thing that wasn't broken about it being perceived as satirising suicide itself, not the way the media and people react to it. We didn't need 13 Reasons Why.